Skip to content
Notes

How Do Bookies Set Odds?

Where a line comes from: the model behind the number, the margin that turns a forecast into a price, what moves it once posted, and the levers an operator has.

By
Mike Casanova
Published
Checked
In this note
6 min read

Nobody starts from a blank page

A line does not start with an operator's opinion about a game. It starts with a price that already exists somewhere else.

At the top of the trade, books employ odds compilers. Wikipedia's description of the job is a person who sets the odds for events, and who monitors the financial position the bookmaker is in and adjusts their position and odds accordingly. Most of the first half of that is now done by a model: results going back years, rest, travel, personnel, whatever the sport rewards, all of it compressed into an expected margin or an expected win rate. A person sits on top of the model and overrules it when something true is not in the data yet.

Independent operators do none of this, and nobody expects them to. They take a feed. The prices arrive already made, on every game they will ever be asked about, at three in the morning as readily as at kickoff. What the operator does with those prices is the actual job, and it is a different job from making them.

Turning a forecast into a price

Suppose the model says one side wins a shade over half the time. That is a probability, not a price. The step between them is where the business lives.

Convert the probability back into odds honestly and you get what is called a fair book: the implied chances of every outcome add up to 100%. Wikipedia's page on the arithmetic of bookmaking walks through an example where three fair prices sum to exactly that, and then shows the same three prices shortened until the book sums to 120%. The 20 points of excess are the overround, and they are the reason the exercise is worth doing at all.

The standard football and basketball price works the same way in smaller numbers. At -110 a bettor risks 110 to win 100, which implies a 52.38% chance of winning. Put that on both sides of a two-way market and the book adds up to 104.76%, so the overround is 4.76 points. Expressed against everything staked rather than against a fair book, that is about 4.55% theoretical margin. Those are the numbers the price card is built around, and how bookies make money follows them through a real week, where players are not obliging enough to bet in neat opposing pairs.

So an odds feed is doing two separate things at once. It is forecasting the game, and it is pricing the forecast. Operators who talk about "the line" usually mean the first. The second is the part that pays them.

The forecast is good, and it knows it is not perfect

It is worth being concrete about how good, because the answer shapes how much energy an operator should spend disagreeing with the number.

Greg Szalkowski and Michael Nelson looked at 2,560 pro football games covering ten seasons, from 2002 to 2011, and checked the lines against what actually happened. Home teams beat the spread 47% of the time. Betting home underdogs across that whole stretch would have returned 53.5%, against the 52.38% a bettor needs at a standard price just to break even. That is a real edge, found with a decade of hindsight, and it is barely more than a point wide.

Read that as an operator rather than as a bettor. The number you are handed each morning is close enough to right that trying to beat it with a hunch is a losing use of your attention. Your edge is not in the forecast. It is in the margin, and in not letting one game put a hole in it.

What moves a price once it is up

Two forces move a posted number, and telling them apart is most of the skill.

The first is information. A key player sits out, a lineup is confirmed late, the weather turns. The forecast genuinely changed, so the price should change with it, and every book gets the same news at roughly the same time.

The second is money. Wikipedia's note on odds compiling puts it plainly: odds are usually not set independently of other bookmakers, and a selection taking heavy volume tends to see its odds cut. When a price moves and no news arrives to explain it, what moved it was the weight of the betting.

For a private book the same logic runs at a much smaller scale, which makes it easier to read and easier to get wrong. Four of your players taking the same side inside an hour is not a market signal about the game. It might only be a group chat. The exposure is real either way, which is why the response is about your book rather than about the sport.

The three levers you actually have

When the money lands one way, an operator has three moves, and all three are legitimate.

You can shade your own number. Push the price on the heavy side a little further from where the feed has it, and make the quiet side a little cheaper. This does not change what happens in the game. It changes which side the next bets want, and it makes the players who are already on the heavy side pay more for the position they wanted.

You can cut the limit on that one game. This is the blunt instrument and it is often the right one, because it caps the problem without touching anyone else's action. Per game and per player limits are set on the agent side rather than in the price.

Or you can carry the position on purpose. Sometimes the honest read is that your players are wrong and you are happy to have the other side of it. That is a decision, and it is fine as long as it is one. Carrying a position because nobody looked is the version that ends seasons.

None of the three is available to an operator who does not know where the exposure sits, which is why the reporting matters more than the pricing screen. The week as it is actually worked covers where that fits between taking a player on and settling up.

What the platform does, and what stays yours

BookiePerHead supplies the prices and the machinery around them. It takes no wagers and holds no player money. Every account, every limit, every price you choose to move and every settlement belongs to the operator.

What arrives with the platform is the feed and the controls: prices across the major sports around the clock, the ability to move your own number on a game, per player and per sport caps, and exposure that updates as bets land rather than after the fact. How the lines reach your players sets out what is covered.

What it costs is a flat weekly fee: $8 per active player on Standard, $11 on Pro, and $13 for live dealer casino if you take it. No percentage of the action in either tier.

The short version is that the hard technical problem, pricing thousands of games well enough that nobody can pick you off, was solved by somebody else and is now rented by the week. The problem that is left is smaller and entirely yours: deciding, game by game, how much of your own money you want riding on a number you did not write.

01Questions

Asked about this

Large books employ people to compile prices. Independent operators almost never do. They take a feed that covers the major sports around the clock and adjust individual prices for their own book when the action calls for it.

A model estimates the likely result, that estimate is converted into a probability, and the probability is converted into a price with a margin added. The margin is why the two sides of a market add up to more than 100% rather than exactly 100%.

Two reasons. News changes what the forecast should be, and money changes where the book's exposure sits. A price that moves without any news behind it is usually telling you about the money.

Close, but not perfect. In a study of 2,560 pro football games over ten seasons, home teams beat the spread only 47% of the time, while a bettor needs 52.38% at a standard price just to break even.

Yes, and it is the main price lever they have. Moving your own number makes the quiet side more attractive and makes the heavy side cost more, which pulls the next bets toward the side you want.

The platform supplies them. It does not decide what you do with them. Shading a price, cutting a limit on one game, or taking a position knowingly are all operator decisions, and so is doing nothing.

02Next

More notes

  1. 6 min read

    How Parlays Are Priced, and Why Books Offer Them

    A parlay multiplies the legs, so it multiplies the margin. The arithmetic, where a fixed card disagrees with it, and the settings an operator should check.

  2. 7 min read

    Reading Line Movement: What It Tells an Operator

    What a moving number actually says: how far a line travels in a week, why a later price is not always better, and why your book's move is not the market's.

  3. 6 min read

    Pro Basketball Season: What Changes for a Book

    Football gives a book one heavy day a week. Basketball gives seven games a night for six months. What that does to limits, live betting and the weekly number.

All notes

03Get a demo

Read enough? See the platform.

Tell us about your book. We reply with a demo login and a time to walk through it on real screens.

On the call

  • A demo login for the player site and the agent backend.
  • Whatever this note left you asking.
  • Your weekly price, and how you pay.

We reply within 24 hours.

Outside American football season and the major playoffs there is a free trial as well; we go over it when we talk.

Are you running a book already?
Preferred language

No long-term commitment. We reply to every request ourselves.